Even DM's make mistakes.

[Anonymous Bosch]

[djspectre]

Honestly, what NC just said is true.

A paladin of mine got hit with a 10pt Evil shift for disarming a guard who was attacking an unarmed woman PC.

I argued against it. Stating that I did not kill the guard, nor intimidate, nor anything evil. I simply evened up the fight by stripping him of his weapon (Imp. Disarm)...which was more chaotic than evil.

The result was that the DM conceded, reversing the evil shift and instead giving me a more deserving chaotic shift.

Though I still th ink 10pts was rather harsh.....