Home > Off Topic Discussion

Debate Ive been having and Trying to raise!

People have always argued Jack Sparrow from Pirates of the Caribean is Chaotic Nuetrel. I however say Chaotic Evil! Lets face it for 1 hes a pirate.

2 The only reasons he ever does acts of kindness are to A save his own SKin or B some kind of personal gain.

3 Hes time and Time again betrayed his own Crew.

4 Sold out william Turner to Jones.

5 Used Williams Disapearence. (wich is infact his fault.) To hit on his Fiance.

6 a bunch of other stuff I have probably forgotten.

Is that the pinnacle question of your philosophical self-enlightment journey, Dr. D?

Sorry DD, gotta go CN here too. He is purely interested in his own skin, but the random killing just isn't there. To say all pirates would be like saying a certain Robert DeNiro pirate is evil as well.

His own skin? He tried to offed Orlando for (dont know her name.) That is evil! To sell someones soul just to get with their Gf is evil. Infact selling somebodys soul is evil SSSSSS! CE CE and CE!

You have to be malicious to be evil. You have to do bad things for the love of doing them and the power it gives you. Therefore, being a conniving pirate doesn't make you evil. :P

CN

Lawful Good.

Jack was saving his own skin in order to balance the primordial powers to stop them from consuming themselves.

If you have questions, you can ask the recent Grand Guide to the Realms. If it's logical to end Faerun with a retarded apocalypse that makes absolutely no sense, then it's logical to make Jack Sparrow Lawful Good!

...

[But yes, he's CN, at worst with tendencies towards Evil]

Id argue the he is....

Wait...

No, I am inable to participate in the conversation, Im still stuck on the debate if a jedi is a Monk/sorc/WM or paladin.

Im sorry, my nerd banks are full.

http://www.darthsanddroids.net/episodes/0004.html

Dr. D, It's time you should know that you are a fool.

Captain Jack Sparrow is very obviously CN, which is defined in two words as a "Free Soul." Selling your jerk friend's soul, (because let's face it, will was about as annoying as the dog that keeps coming back in the film.) is something anyone of us would do in Jack's situation. Hmmmmm. let's see. Eternal Service to Davy Jones' Crew or give my annoying friend to him, (because, chances are, Jones would eventually free Will to save himself from the constant annoyance.) and go free. Plus, Cap'n Jack Sparrow never just killed anyone for no reason. A must for CE.

IMO Jack Sparrow is just a hottie.

IMO;

moar cannons and cannonballs for EFU plz!

CN or CE, I think we're all missing the bigger picture here.

^_^

Semli CN or CE, I think we're all missing the bigger picture here.

^_^

Yes, we definately are. It's not possible to see it. >_<

THAR BE NO BIGGOR PICTAR YARR

btw, I'd like to remind all of you that at the end of the third movie Jack has a chance to become immortal, he could stab jones' heart and become an immortal terror of the seas, but instead he had Will stab the heart, to save Will's life, which was very close to over. And so jack sacrificed his chances at immortality to save his annoying friend Will Turner.

Well so? it was a tactical Decision! Jack didnt want to be immortal!

Plus it wasnt jack that cut wills heart and put it in the chest! Jack just left his corpse and bootleg cut his heart and put it in the chest!

Whaaaat?

Captain Jack's entire goal in life is to become immortal and sail the seas forever!

The only argument you could make is that Jack decided against stabbing the heart was because he didn't want to do the job of ferrying souls.

Jack is CN, and it's definitely not a hard thing to determine! He compulsively looks out for Number one, but also has a conscience. When has he ever deliberately hurt or killed an innocent person?

Not evil. Just greedy and chaotic.

DrD Trolling ftw